【World Life】とは?

Did Tokyo University get it wrong?

World Lifeな生活
この記事は約5分で読めます。

Hi, this is Jiro.

Recently, I was very very surprised to watch ‘’Here comes Darwin!’’ (ダーウィンが来た),an NHK TV program, where a Japanese scientist Toshitaka Suzuki reportedly discovered that some birds have a language in the true sense of the word for the first time in the world.

I couldn’t help but remember telling my students that animals had no language at all, humans being the only creatures that do.

Shortly after that, in 2023 Suzuki got a position in prestigious Tokyo University, establishing Animal linguistics, invited as a guest speaker at International Animal Behavior Science Convention, admired and shown respect to by a long line of scientists.

Thus my conviction that human beings are not the only creature with a language had become so strong as to leave no
room for doubt.

imagine my greater surprise in 2024 when, looking for teaching materials for a few students I would give private lessons to, I came across an entrance exam of Tokyo University where was used an English scientific paper insisting that human beings ARE the only creature with a language, and that in 2024(I repeat)one year after Suzuki established Animal linguistics in
the very University that gave this anachronistic exam to all the aspirants.

To cite from the exam in question:The aspects of human life that make our species unique depend …. on the special human ability to use language. …only humans have languages in the strict   sense…

What’s going on, I wondered? Is there no respect to those young people who, looking up to Tokyo University, must have worked so hard for the once in-a-year exam? I couldn’t help but resent this gross oversight or indifference.

There have been problematic exam questions before. For example:
「私は生まれも育ちも埼玉ばあさんです」Saitama University
(I was born and raised in Saitama, and now am flourishing as Saitama Grandma.)
「美人は早く死ぬ。そうでない人は長生きすべき」Nara Women University
(Beauties die young. Those who are otherwise are wise to live long.)

This time, however, the implication far exceeds preceding cases, I think, in scale and… in humor as well, for, this year, Tokyo University asked this:Write in English,

what does it mean to be strong? in 60–80 words.

Thinking highly of this question as it encourages deep and creative thinking on the part of examinees, is this because Todai is sorry about what it did the preceding year and trying to make it up with this good question this year, I said to myself?

I will let you know if I ever find anything interesting again.

タイトルとURLをコピーしました